Best Seafood Key West – 9 Places That Seafood Lovers Must Try

Best Seafood Key West – 9 Places That Seafood Lovers Must Try

Best Seafood Key West

Many visitors to the Florida Keys quickly realize that the food in Key West is not to be missed since it offers a unique blend of flavors and influences from cuisines from the Caribbean, Cuba, and Florida. Fresh seafood, dishes made with conch, and key lime pies are some of its best-known specialties.

Consuming dishes prepared using regional ingredients is an excellent method to gain exposure to the culture and spirit of a particular location. In addition, there is a thriving restaurant scene in Key West, and visitors have their pick of several outstanding dining establishments.

Where should one go first if they want to try some of the most delicious seafood that Key West has to offer? Which of these dishes—fish tacos, stone crab claws, or lobster rolls—do you want?

Keep reading for additional information on where to locate the best seafood in Key West, as well as advice on the seafood restaurants on the island that specialize in certain dishes.

The Best Seafood Key West Has To Offer

1) Try The Daily Catch At Eaton Street Seafood Market

Eaton Street Seafood Market is a popular seafood market located in Key West, Florida. The market provides customers with access to a comprehensive selection of fresh local seafood in the form of fish, shellfish, and other seafood-related products.

It’s also a great place to find some unique seafood and seafood products not found elsewhere. Some special points about the market include:

  • The seafood sold at Eaton Street Seafood Market is believed to be some of the freshest in the region, as it is caught by local fishermen.
  • The market sells additional products, such as pre-made seafood meals, spices, and sauces.
  • The market is frequented by a large number of locals as well as tourists who are interested in trying the regional seafood delicacies.
  • The market features a modest deli counter where customers can purchase to-go items such as sandwiches, salads, and other fish dishes.

2) Enjoy A Moderately Priced Dinner At Seven Fish

Seven Fish is a restaurant known for its seafood-centric menu and laid-back atmosphere and is one of the best seafood restaurants on the island. The menu includes a number of seafood meals, some of which are made with fish that was caught locally.

It is well known for the high quality of its seafood and the great service it provides. Tourists who visit this lovely restaurant appreciate:

  • There is a choice of meat, chicken, and vegetarian options.
  • The restaurant is known for its seafood creations, and its menu changes daily depending on the catch.
  • Seven Fish offers a unique blend of Caribbean, Floridian, and Southern cuisines.
  • The restaurant is a terrific location to unwind and relax due to its laid-back vibe and ambiance.
  • It has an extensive wine list and a complete bar, stocked with a variety of local beers and tropical drinks.

3) The Ocean Key Resort Dining Options Are Convenient

The Ocean Key is a luxury resort that can be found in Key West, Florida, and it provides its visitors with a number of different dining options to choose from:

  • Hot Tin Roof is a multi-award-winning restaurant that features contemporary American cuisine and is consistently voted as one of the most popular dining options at the resort. The restaurant offers to seat both inside and out, and guests may enjoy breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico from either option.
  • Sunset Pier is yet another well-liked alternative, and it has both a restaurant and a bar that are open-air. Sunset Pier provides tropical beverages and seafood such as steamed clams, seafood pasta, and shrimp tacos. The restaurant is perched on the end of a pier and provides breathtaking panoramas of the sun setting over the water.
  • The resort features a poolside bar and grill known as the Sunset Tiki Bar & Grill, which offers a selection of light fare and exotic beverages.
  • The resort also features a coffee shop known as Java and a deli known as The Market, both of which offer quick eating options, some seafood based.

4) Dj’s Clam Shack Is For Shellfish Lovers!

DJ’s Clam Shack is recognized for its delicious seafood, friendly service, and laid-back ambiance. It is a casual seafood restaurant that is popular with both residents and tourists.

The restaurant boasts a stunning panorama of the Gulf of Mexico due to its waterfront setting and proximity to the ocean. Because they have earned a stellar reputation for both their conch fritters and their lobster rolls, the gourmet traveler should make it a priority to stop by this restaurant over other seafood restaurants.

DJ’s is special because:

  • At DJ’s Clam Shack, you may choose from a wide selection of seafood meals, such as clams, oysters, shrimp, fish, and even conch fritters.
  • It is especially well-known for the house specialty “DJ’s Clam Shack Special,” which is a dish consisting of fried clams, shrimp, scallops, and fish.
  • They have a selection of sandwiches, salads, and other dishes that feature seafood.

5) Conch Republic Seafood Company

This eatery is well-known for the high quality of its seafood and the exotic ambiance it exudes. In addition to a range of sandwiches, salads, and further seafood offerings, the menu includes a variety of seafood options, such as fish, shrimp, and conch, as well as other specialty dishes.

Here are some interesting points about Conch Republic Seafood Market:

  • The restaurant is well-known for its several dishes that feature conch, such as conch soup, conch fritters, and conch ceviche.
  • They have an excellent reputation for their seafood platters, which are a good way to sample a number of distinct types of seafood all at once.
  • Customers have access to a market that is connected to the restaurant at the Conch Republic Fish Company where they may buy freshly caught seafood and things related to seafood to take home with them.
  • The market carries a broad selection of local seafood, such as fish, shellfish, and other items. Additionally, the market provides a selection of seasonings, sauces, and seafood dishes that have been pre-prepared.

6) A&B Lobster House And Restaurant Is Best For High-End Dining

The A&B Lobster House is well-known for its high-quality cuisine and the gourmet seafood it serves. In addition to a selection of meats, poultry, and pasta meals, the menu offers a selection of seafood options, including fish, shrimp, and lobster, as well as other seafood options.

If you like fine dining, consider these special points:

  • A&B is especially well known for its lobster dishes, such as the lobster tail, lobster mac & cheese, and lobster bisque.
  • As befits its status as an expensive establishment, the cafe is outfitted with a formal dining area that features white tablecloths and a strict dress code.
  • The menu is quite comprehensive, and the chefs have a stellar reputation for their inventiveness and their use of seasonal and regional foods.
  • The restaurant features a well-stocked bar as well as an extensive wine list.
  • The restaurant is only open for dinner, and guests are strongly encouraged to make reservations in advance.

7) Salty’s Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill Is Popular For Casual Dining

The laid-back ambiance and delicious seafood at Salty’s Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill have earned it a reputation for excellence and amazing food. On the menu, you’ll find a selection of seafood dishes, such as oysters, fish, shrimp, and conch, along with a choice of sandwiches, salads, and additional seafood concoctions.

The oyster dishes at this seafood restaurant, such as oyster shooters, oyster Rockefeller, fried oysters, and grilled oysters, have earned the establishment a reputation for being particularly noteworthy. In addition to this, they have an excellent reputation for their raw bar, which features a selection of fresh raw oysters and clams in a number of preparations.

Salty’s offers a relaxed and laid-back attitude, and it is a wonderful location to unwind while enjoying some freshly prepared seafood and the ocean view.

8) Pincher’s Is The Crab Lover’s Paradise!

On the menu at Pincher’s, you’ll find a wide selection of fresh catch seafood fare in addition to a selection of sandwiches, salads, and other seafood dishes. Crab is featured prominently in a number of meals offered at this eatery, including crab cakes, crab legs, and crab dip, among others.

They have a stellar reputation for the quality of their fresh fish specialties and the extensive selection of seafood meals they provide on their menu. Some highlights of this restaurant include:

  • Pincher’s features a well-stocked bar in addition to a comprehensive drink menu that offers a wide selection of alcoholic beverages, including a number of different kinds of beers and cocktails.
  • There is a beautiful and relaxing outdoor seating area.
  • The restaurant serves both lunch and dinner, and reservations are not normally required to eat there as with many Key West seafood restaurants.
  • It is a wonderful place to enjoy an unpretentious supper of seafood and a drink after a long day.

9) Dinner Cruises

How about dinner on the ocean? Dinner cruises are among the most well-liked things to do in the Florida Keys and usually consist of taking a boat ride around the region while having a meal on board. Key West Boat Trips offers dinner cruises throughout the week with beautiful scenery and delicious seafood. Visitors can feast on Key West pink shrimp, stone crab, and crab cake sandwiches while admiring the ocean view.

On our Key West Dinner Cruise, some of the most well-liked activities are watching the sunset and looking for dolphins as your meal is prepared. Activities such as snorkeling and swimming are often available as options on our dinner cruises. 

Reserve Your Table!

In conclusion, Key West offers a wide variety of seafood dining options for visitors to enjoy, and it is not difficult to find a good seafood restaurant located anywhere near your location on the island. From fine dining experiences at upscale resorts to casual seafood shacks and waterfront restaurants, there is something for everyone.

The island’s location on the Gulf of Mexico allows for an abundance of delicious seafood to be served, and many restaurants take advantage of this by featuring seafood prominently on their menus. Whether you’re in the mood for a fancy dinner or a laid-back lunch, fish tacos, or stone crab, Key West has plenty of local seafood options to choose from. With beautiful ocean views and the perfect tropical weather, it’s the perfect place to indulge in fresh seafood while enjoying a vacation.

Contact Key West Boat Trips today and make a reservation online for up to 6 guests for your dinner cruise!

Ready for your next adventure?